What is the priority at Government’s Economic Reform Roundtable?

The Treasurer is looking for consensus on how to solve our productivity problem from a group of economic leaders. That is admirable but I think they first they must come to a common understanding of the problem itself, before moving into ‘solution’ mode. Productivity is not the problem; it is a symptom of the underlying problem.

The Productivity Commission (PC) in its recently released interim report outlined the broad drivers of productivity growth:

“Productivity growth can come about through several channels: 

  • Investment that increases the amount of capital per worker (capital deepening) 
  • Improvements in education and worker skills (human capital)
  • More efficient uses of capital and labour (resource allocation)
  • New technologies. 

Not all channels are created equal”

I think that these broad buckets are correct, but the issue is how to assess each of these in terms of what is happening in Australia in 2025 and over the decade ahead. Why are we not getting enough ‘capital deepening’? What is holding back the development and deployment of our human capital? Why are labour and capital resources not being efficiently allocated? And the big one; how do we encourage the adoption of incredible new digital capabilities to drive higher output per worker (i.e. productivity)?

Rather than jump into solution mode with tax proposals, regulatory reform suggestions and other policy changes; the time would be best spent on driving a consensus about what is happening in the economy to not only hinder productivity improvement, but more recently cause an unprecedented decline in our economies productivity level

Why are the four economic processes identified by the PC not delivering the productivity growth we once had. Indeed, what is happening to drive productivity down by more than 5% over the last three years?

Bottom Line: we must solve for the right problem.  Once we have a consensus on the problem, finding workable solutions will be much easier, and of course, the solutions will have a much better chance of success.

Without meaningful reform, where is the economy headed over the next two decades?

Most longer-term projections are a bit ‘wishy-washy’. And the analytics underpinning many projections are subject to the same issue of ‘problem’ identification. There are a whole range of views, many of them come from the perspective of a particular interest group, some assessments are unhelpful.

I think the best assessment of the problem came from the RBA in their latest set of economic forecasts. These forecasts cover the next 3 years (to 2027) which isn’t the time horizon that fundamental economic reform can have much impact on. The RBA Governor said as much. Fundamental and effective reform will be aimed at the medium to long term performance of the economy. But this should not be a reason for complacency. We are already experiencing a productivity slump; a crisis of economic performance. Implementation lead times mean that there is a real urgency about the reform task.

The August 2025 projections from the RBA depict an economy devoid of dynamism. Business investment hardly grows over the next few years, consumer spending is soft by historical standards, and the main driver of overall economic growth is government spending. The RBA revised down their productivity projection to a still optimistic 0.7% a year and even then we see little growth in real wages and living standards. 

The message I take from the RBA’s latest forecasts, coming right before the Roundtable, is:

“If we as a nation do not start addressing our productivity performance, then this 2 year economic outlook is what we should expect to see from the Australian economy over the long term”. 

Quite the wake-up call. 

The most important element of the RBA forecast is how weak business investment is projected to be. Little investment in technology; little capital deepening and hence little improvement in worker productivity. There is more to it that just business investment. The real problem we face is a less efficient allocation of our increasingly scare labour resources. We are not ensuring that our people, our workers are being set to the most productive tasks in the economy. 

This is partly a result of skills mismatches in a changing world, partly the result of government taking a much bigger role in the allocation of labour resources through the massive expansion of funding (spending) into the care economy. It is also a problem of labour market flexibility. Our people cannot move jobs easily. We have seen job mobility in Australia decline to record lows in 2025 to be one of the lowest of the advanced economies.

The last time we saw broad ranging economic reform was in the 1980/90s with a range of stakeholders working together to change the economy in fundamental ways. What do you think can be credited for its success? 

The wave of reform from the 1980s fundamentally changed the Australian economy, opening it up to the world (embracing free trade) and allowing the price mechanism (flexible markets) to take a greater role in determining how the economy allocated resources.

The changes to our economy did not come without costs and disruption to our communities.

These reforms came after a decade of reviews and reports that focused in on the core problem – an over regulated and protected economy. Throughout the 1970s the issue of poor economic performance was clear (high unemployment, high inflation and weak productivity growth). By the mid-1980s the core problem was widely understood – we needed a more market orientated economy to drive resource allocation rather than government regulation. A consensus emerged. 

Once the problem was understood the debate became about the best solutions (policy changes) to get us there. When the problem is known, all interested parties can come to the table and have a constructive debate.

These reforms, particularly the first wave in the 1980s, came with real short-term costs to our economy and it would be ludicrous to suggest mistakes were not made. But the result was one of the best complex industrial economies the world has ever seen. 

Australia became the ‘miracle economy’. We initiated a productivity boom that made us one of the wealthiest economies in the world, one that raised the living standards of all Australians. We also created an adaptable and flexible economy that was able to navigate shock after shock from the Asian financial crisis of 1997, to the ‘Tech Wreck’ of 2001, the GFC and the European debt crisis. We executed one of the biggest resource investments in human history without a boom-bust recession. 

We got lucky on many fronts. But the catalyst was leadership and vision, and the use of good economics to underpin the reform agenda.

There were short-term costs to be sure, but the benefits derived to all Australians massively outweighed these costs. And we can learn from the mistakes of the 1980s and 1990s this time. How to support people through difficult transitions and changed circumstances.

There has been a shift in our labour force in the past decade with the retirement of the ‘Baby Boomer’ generation. 

The demographic shift is at the core of our economic problem and although we can’t change these demographic realities all that much, we must accept that the economic landscape is shifting. As a community, and within our economic leadership, we are yet to fully understand just how profound these demographic changes are to the underlying functioning of our economy.

What does the big shift in our demographic structure mean for our economy? 

From the early 1970s until about 2010 we had the baby boomer generation entering the world force in increasing numbers. The traditional working age share of the population was increasing every year. Total population is a broad measure of demand in the economy while the working age population is a broad measure of the supply capacity of the economy, that is, the people who are available to work to supply the goods and services that the overall population needs. These are broad assessments, and other factors play a role, but it is the main game and most importantly, demographic trends are persistent – they are not going away.

To be clear – from 1970s to 2010 each year we had more working age population coming into the economy than the increase in population/demand. It was a period of labour abundance were finding jobs for everyone was the big challenge.  Unemployment was a major economic problem to be solved.

We have now shifted 180 degrees and each year we are seeing less and less working age population (supply) compared to population (demand) – and hence we are now in an era of labour scarcity – unemployment is no longer a macroeconomic issue – the real focus is microeconomic: how to get our scare labour supply, the workers of Australia, into the most productive jobs. We are already seeing this in our economy (job vacancies for example are well above the long-term trend and the ratio to the number of unemployed is at extremes (since the survey commenced in 1979).

While it is credit to our government that they have been producing the Inter-Generational Report (IGR) for the past 25 years in an attempt to address these big changes; the problem is they have missed the point on how these demographic changes are altering the underlying functioning of the economy. The focus has been on the impact of rising old age dependency on the government’s budget and the impact of a slowing relative workforce growth on income tax revenues.

A cynical interpretation of the IGR process is that it has been a ‘trojan horse’ for big government. An excuse to break with three decades of government financial discipline and start throwing taxpayer money around like confetti.

What has Australia been doing to address the demographic shift?

The main thing we have been doing is increasing government spending, and taxation, with the last three years showcasing this process in the federal governments care economy strategy.

Out there on main street, the way we have been coping with labour shortages is by dragging people into the workforce and taking our participation rate (those in labour force) to record high levels. Mainly through increasing how many people aged over 65 years old that are actively participating in work. Whether this is a good or bad thing is not the issue, the issue is how far can we push our population to work, particularly in older age. Eventually this will reach a limit but the demographic trend will remain in place well into the middle of the century.

Bottom line: we have largely offset the demographic deterioration of the last 15 years and its effect on the economy and inflation by increasing participation.

What does Australia need to do to address this? 

The Government needs to accept the reality that workers are an increasingly scarce resource in our economy and if we do not allow our workforce to adjust, if we do not encourage re-skilling, if we do not encourage business and other organisation to invest in labour saving technology, then we will continue to see our living standards go backwards as productivity erodes. 

We need to allow people to move to the most important jobs. Essentially, we need to have a more flexible labour market, but we also need government to play a role in making this process easier for everyone, most importantly workers but also business. We need to make changing jobs and reskilling a much more seamless and less distressing process that what has been in the past. But their IR agenda of the last three years has gone in the opposite direction.

Why can’t immigration solve this problem? 

At first glance you would think immigration and bringing in labour and skills would be a big part of the solution to this problem. It helps but it is no ‘silver bullet’.

Why? If a firm needs a particular skill set, let’s say an electrician, and can’t find anyone in Australia. Lets say the particular firm identifies a person in NZ, and finds a suitable Visa program to allow that person to emigrate here and work for the firm. The firm has solved their labour shortage. But the economy has not solved its problem because the worker from NZ brings in demand with them. They need housing, roads, hospitals etc. The overall economic imbalance between supply and demand is not solved. It helps, but only at the margin, and as we have seen with the immigration surge, rapid immigration brings with it major issues around housing, health etc. 

What about the role of technology in solving this, things like quantum computing and AI?

This is the good news. Rather than being some threat to our society or way of life, these new digital technologies are here to ‘save the day’. Unlike the experience of the 1990s, when we started to see a big reduction in our manufacturing sector, the loss of jobs back then was at a time of labour abundance; we were struggling to find jobs for new workers let alone jobs for structurally displaced workers in manufacturing. Haunting statistic: half the men over the age of 45years old that lost their job in manufacturing in early 1990s, never worked again.

This is a terrible outcome. And this is the type of experience that is colouring some peoples view of AI. But the world has changed. We need all hands-on deck. AI will displace jobs; this time it is likely to be a wave of female workers in the services sector. But we cannot afford to lose those workers from the workforce; they need to be re-training and skilled for the human centred jobs that computers and drones and bots can’t do.

Many people are coming at the AI problem all the wrong way: they are worried about job losses like we saw with manufacturing in the early 1990s. But the critical context is that we have structural labour shortages. And this is an example where we need a consensus from the Roundtable. And an example of how the Treasurer needs to stand up to certain groups, not least the union ,movement, that is failing to see this perspective and getting in the way of getting the right solution. Ideally, we would see the emergence of leaders in the union movement that understand these new realities and ‘manage to’ them, rather than ignore or deny the realities and seek other pathways for economic policy. 

We need to swim with the tide, not against it. This is a prime example; although not the only one of why a consensus around the ‘problem’ is so important.

We have a labour force that’s in relative decline compared to the size of the economy, where are we heading? 

If we cannot get that consensus on the nature of our productivity problem then we are on a long run path that looks like the RBA’s latest set of forecasts, probably worse. It is an economic path not too dissimilar to Japan over the last 25 years; a pathway characterised by government dominance, massive government budget deficits and massive government debt. Japan’s government is in real trouble. We have total government debt (state and federal) of around 40-50% of GDP; low by international standards. The Us and Europeans are very worried with government debts around 100% to 125% of GDP. Japan has government debt of 250% of GDP. The emergence of inflation in Japan is pushing up interest rates for the first time in 30 years. Long term interest rates have pushed above 3% for the first time in more than 40 years over the past three months. Japan is the proverbial canary in the coalmine on these demographic shifts and how to manage the economy.

But we look like we are in the early stages of taking the ‘Japan route’. Government spending is surging, masked in terms of budget position but a massive increase in income taxes via bracket creep. But we are now in deficit, and it does not look good. The government programs put in place in the past three years are increasingly expensive and will put more pressure on government finances and we will see a desire for higher taxation and of course, higher budget deficits.

The Australian economy is very different to Japan’s. We have the highest household debt in the world thanks to some of the most unaffordable housing in the world. We push too hard on government borrowing and there will be pressure brought to bear on the housing markets and household finances. Much more than what we have seen over the last three years. Our economy will not cope. The massive taxation of the tobacco market in the past 3 years is a salient warning about the effects of high taxation. It is an illusion. All they have done is created one of the biggest new sources of funding for organised crime in history. And reduced the tax take, putting more pressure on income taxes to fund the growing public spending in our society.

You have said that Australia is not well positioned for this new demographic reality with one of the lowest rates of job mobility in the world, why? And what do we need to do to fix this?

If we want to allow our society and economy to adjust to new realities, a big part of this is a reordering of the labour market. AI will touch most jobs and could maker up to 30% of roles redundant over the next 20 years. Rather than resist and regulate, we need to work out ways to encourage firms and workers to adjust. This implies a big pick up in job mobility, at odds with the long-term trend for declining job mobility, which is right on record lows. Australia has a particularly immobile labour force compared to other nations. We are not well placed to confront these new realities.

At what point do we drop the political footballing around our economic challenges and start leading people through difficult change? And how crucial is this?

It is the old story: do we get ahead of the problem, and start making the necessary adjustments, or do we wait for an economic catastrophe to provide the wake up call? We are already seeing the consequences of an immobile workforce showing up in the economy. We are already seeing the impact of big government spending on the economy. The lights are flashing amber. It takes incredible political courage and skill to undertake genuine reform. I am not that confident given the disposition of the current government.

It looks like we risk heading down the Japan route. Japan has been treading water for 30 years, but the recent rise of inflation and interest rates could be the start of some big adjustments in that economy.

I very much doubt that Australia can use government deficit spending to paper over our problems for the next 30 years. It would put too much pressure on our existing economic and financial structures. Structures that formed up over a period of high productivity and real income growth. Financial structures like high household debt will not stand up to a persistent decline in real incomes. Reality will catch up with us pretty quickly. Whether that be another inflation surge that drives interest rates higher or a default cycle that disrupts the banking system; I am not convinced we can remain in this government dominated economy for too much longer. Maybe another 5 years; could be a bit longer. Certainly not 30 years.

At what point do we admit that our economy is not adjusting to the realities of the world? And what are some of those realities?

As a community we are too focused on the ageing issue being about service provision to older Australians. We have been too dependent on government directed outcomes such as the child and age care policies of the last 3 years. We are not focused enough on economic functioning and dynamism. We can see the problems in Japan, parts of Europe. The political challenge might prove too great, however. 

We are seeing how a flexible private sector led economy is benefitting from new technology in the case of the US. US productivity is surging ahead of other advanced nations. They are creating an even bigger and more resilient economy through technological absorption. We are only at the start of this technological journey. 

Whether it be labour market reform, more disciplined government spending or policies that support and encourage the new digital capabilities, we are at risk of falling behind the ‘technological frontier’. 

I think we are already admitting it to some extent. The issue is whether we can act decisively to make the required policy adjustments that will allow the economy and all those in it to harness and apply new technology to our everyday lives.